Congress investigates delayed Great Lakes reportTRAVERSE CITY, Mich. — A U.S. House panel will investigate why a federal agency is withholding a report describing potential health threats
By: By JOHN FLESHER/AP Environmental Writer, The Daily Telegram
TRAVERSE CITY, Mich. — A U.S. House panel will investigate why a federal agency is withholding a report describing potential health threats near 26 heavily polluted areas in the Great Lakes region, lawmakers said Thursday.
The handling of the matter by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ‘‘raises grave questions about the integrity of scientific research’’ at the agency, ‘‘as well as the treatment of its scientists,’’ Reps. John Dingell and Bart Stupak said in a letter to CDC Director Dr. Julie Louise Gerberding.
Dingell is chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, while Stupak is chairman of its Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee. Both are Michigan Democrats.
Messages seeking comment were left with a CDC spokesman in Atlanta. The agency said earlier this month the report was being revised to correct flaws and would be issued later.
The Center for Public Integrity, a nonprofit journalism organization in Washington, D.C., earlier published what it said were excerpts from a version that had been scheduled for release last July.
It said many of the counties where the 26 ‘‘areas of concern’’ are located have abnormally high rates of cancer and other health problems such as infant mortality, low birth weight and premature births. Detroit, Chicago, Cleveland and Milwaukee are among the areas of concern.
Altogether, the areas have more than 100 sites polluted with toxic wastes such as PCBs, mercury and dioxins, the report said. Of those, 71 were identified as having ‘‘a potential human health impact.’’
The report doesn’t say the waste sites caused the health problems but raises questions for further study, according to scientists who have reviewed it.
But Dingell and Stupak said if its conclusions are accurate, ‘‘the health of millions of people in the Great Lakes region may be at risk.’’
The CDC’s Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry conducted the study. It was requested in 2001 by the International Joint Commission, an independent panel that advises U.S. and Canadian officials on Great Lakes water quality issues.
A CDC spokesman said previously that reviewers found weaknesses in the study, including correlation of environmental data from specific toxic waste sites with health data from entire counties. The waste sites typically occupy small parts of one or more counties.
Dingell and Stupak asked the CDC for records involving the decision to withhold the report. They requested copies of communications between Christopher De Rosa, the scientist who led the study, and his superiors — Gerberding and Dr. Howard Frumkin, director of the toxics agency.
‘‘The validity of the findings in this report deserve a fair and open debate within the scientific community,’’ Dingell and Stupak said.